Insights

Andrew Robins

Published 7 May 2025
B0BEFAB3-7AF0-49F8-86B2-AD99CC6EC993
image

Building Liability Orders Update

The Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA) introduced new rights and powers for tenants and property owners to help make homes safer and redress various failings. This included the introduction of Building Liability Orders which are designed to ensure corporate bodies associated with a building are held accountable for building safety risks where appropriate.

Whilst there may be much to be applauded in respect of this new legislation, it is still very much unchartered territory and property developers need to be aware of this new approach by the courts. There have now been a few cases in respect of the BSA and in March 2025, the first Building Liability Order was granted in the case of 381 Southwark Park Road RTM Company & Ord v Click St Andrews Ltd & Anor.

The background to the legislation

Of course, there are often complex corporate structures involved in property development with subsidiaries, shell companies, special purpose vehicles (SPVs) and joint venture companies (JVs) sitting behind the front of house developer. It is not uncommon for these SPVs or JVs or to be wound up post completion with assets transferred elsewhere. The BSA legislation recognises that this can leave owners and residents with difficulties enforcing claims or recovering any money in respect of defects. But it also means that for property developers, and the companies behind them financing a project, the courts will now be “lifting the corporate veil”, thereby putting them at risk of a claim in a way that has not been experienced before.

Building Liability Order

Under section 130 of the BSA, the High Court can grant a Building Liability Order if they consider it “just and equitable” to do so. Such an order extends the “relevant liability” of a corporate body so that an associated body corporate also becomes liable. Or in other words, the claimant will be able to bring a claim against the main contractor and the associated corporation behind the main contractor for safety defects.

The BSA defines a “relevant liability” as a liability incurred either:

  • Under the Defective Premises Act 1972 (DPA 1972),
  • Under section 38 of the Building Act 1984, or
  • As a result of a “building safety risk”.

The first Building Liability Order

In March 2025, a High Court judge granted the first Building Liability Order in the case of 381 Southwark Park Road RTM Company & Ord v Click St Andrews Ltd & Anor.

In this case, a claim was brought by leaseholders (in part by way of a right to manage company) in respect of defects and damage at a residential housing block in London. The claim was brought against the developer, Click St Andrews. However, Click St Andrews was a SPV that went into liquidation shortly after proceedings commenced. Click St Andrews was also a subsidiary company wholly owned by Click Group Holdings Ltd. The Click Group were the second defendants.

The court found that Click St Andrews was liable for building safety risks due to structural issues, namely fire and structural safety breaches. These amounted to a “building safety risk” and therefore came within the remit of a “relevant liability”. As a result, the judge granted a Building Liability Order against Click Group Holdings as the ultimate parent company.

The judge reached her decision by way of a two-stage process:

  1. By deciding whether there was a relevant liability. This was found to be the case in this instance because inadequate fire protection and structural inadequacies breached the Freehold Purchase Agreement which the parties had entered into in 2020, and this gave rise to a “building safety risk” and a “relevant liability”.

The judge also concluded that a failure to comply with design standards relating to structural safety can amount to a “relevant liability” even if no damage has yet occurred.

  • By addressing whether and when it will be just and equitable to make a Building Liability Order. In respect of this, the judge found that the intent behind the legislation is to prevent corporate groups from evading liability through complex corporate structures particularly when “a wealthy parent company or other wealthy entity” is behind a “thinly capitalized or insolvent development company”. However, the court also found that the financial strength of the associated company was not the decisive factor, whereas the control element was.

The judge noted that there remains a lack of clarity about the correct procedure for seeking a Building Liability Order and whether an associated company has to be identified or joined to the substantive proceeding.   

Other recent decisions 

In another March 2025 decision, BDW Trading Ltd v Ardmore Construction Ltd and other companies [2025] EWHC 434 (TCC), the court commented that there was nothing in section 130 that requires a finding of relevant liability against the original developer / company before the granting of a Building Liability Order against an associated company. This means that potentially a party successfully applying for a Building Liability Order before determination of the original body corporate’s liability, is effectively securing an indemnity in the event of an unsuccessful outcome for them in the main proceedings.  

In the ongoing case of Wilmott Dixon -v- Prater and others, there are claims in respective of defective materials and multiple defendants. One of those defendants has brought a claim for a Building Liability Order against the parent companies of some of the other defendants, seeking a contribution if the case goes against them.

The final hearing is expected later this year, but the judge has already ruled that a party seeking a Building Liability Order is not obliged to bring its claim for such an order at the same time as the primary claim against a related company. That said, if a Building Liability Order is claimed before the resolution of a primary claim, the judge indicated the correct approach would normally be to have that claim heard and dealt with at the same time as the primary claim.

The judge also noted that it was possible to be “just and equitable” to grant a Building Liability Order where the primary company had disposed of assets even if they had done so innocently and not by way of an “asset strip”.

Comment and advice for developers

This is a fast-developing area, and more decisions are expected this year.  Arguments in support of a Building Liability Order and guidance as to when they will be granted are likely to evolve over the coming months and years.

Although it may in some circumstances be possible to resist a Building Liability Order on the grounds of either liability or that it’s not just and equitable to grant one, the fact that the other party has Professional Indemnity Insurance in place is not necessarily going to be sufficient to prevent a claim against an associated party.

Now, therefore, is the time to seek legal advice both in respect of any financial / corporate structures behind a development project (or proposed project), your risk of being joined as a party in any current proceedings and any grounds you may have of defending against the granting of a Building Liability Order.

If you would like to discuss any of the issues raised in this article, please get in touch.

The legal content provided by RSW Law Limited is for information purposes only and should not be relied on in any specific case without legal or other professional advice.

Copyright is owned by RSW Law Limited and all rights in such copyright are reserved. Material is not to be reproduced in whole or in part without prior written consent.