CNM Estates
Guidance on relief from sanctions and late applications to amend
In March 2023, the Court of Appeal handed down judgment in the case of CNM Estates (Tolworth Tower) Ltd v Carvill-Biggs & Anor [2023] EWCA Civ 480. It’s a case in which RSW Law acted for the claimant in the Court of Appeal. The judgement related to three issues, namely:
- Whether relief from sanctions was required
- The principles applicable to late applications to amend
- Re-consideration of both CNM’s proposed amendments
The facts
In October 2015, the claimant company, CNM, bought a property for approximately £60.5 million including acquisition costs, of which £54 million was funded by loans. In 2017, CNM fell into default on the loans and instructed estate agents to market the property for sale. Before the marketing had begun, however, receivers were appointed pursuant to the lender’s rights under the mortgage and debenture which formed part of the security for the loans.
The receivers engaged Knight Frank who commenced marketing and in December 2017, the receivers entered into a contract of sale of the property to a third party for the total outstanding balance on the loan. CNM contented the price agreed was below the true market value and issued proceedings on the basis that the receivers had breached their equitable duties to exercise proper skill and care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable on the sale of the development site.
The preliminary issue
In June 2020, at the trial of a preliminary issue, the judge held that:
- The receivers would only be liable for breach of an equitable duty of care owed to CNM where the liability in question was directly caused by the receivers’ gross negligence or wilful misconduct
- CNM had not pleaded a case of gross negligence or of wilful misconduct in its original pleadings
Permission to appeal this decision was refused and therefore, unless amended, the claim was bound to fail.
Unless order
In April 2021, CNM indicated its intention to seek permission to amend. In November 2021, CNM agreed the terms of an Unless order that provided they must file and serve draft Re-Re-Amended Particulars of Claim by 4 pm on the 14th January 2022, failing which the claim would be struck out.
On the 14th of January 2022, CNM served a draft pleading which pleaded a case of wilful misconduct. It did not make an allegation of gross negligence. Nor did it make a formal application to amend. In May 2022, CMM issued an application to amend, attached to which were re-re-amended Particulars of Claim which, this time, included a plea of gross negligence as well as wilful misconduct.
On determining the matter, the judge at first instance held that CNM was in breach of the Unless order and would therefore require relief from sanctions to advance the case of gross negligence which she refused.
In respect of the wilful misconduct, the judge refused permission to amend and identified the principal relevant factors to be taken into account when exercising the discretion to be: “the lateness of the application, any reasons for delay, the adequacy of the pleading and whether it had a real prospect of success, of which the latter two were the most important.”
The Court of Appeal decision
Was Relief from Sanctions Required?
The Court of Appeal held that the Unless order undoubtedly imposed a sanction namely that CNM was to serve a draft amendment to its Particulars of Claim within the specified deadline, failing which their claim would be struck out. However, CNM had complied with that order. Therefore there was no requirement for relief from sanction and the judge should have considered the proposed amendment pleading gross negligence on its merits on the same basis as she considered the application to advance the case of wilful misconduct.
The Principles Applicable to Applications to Amend
The Court of Appeal judgement started by reiterating that the proposed amendments were not “very late” (within the meaning of Quah Su-Ling v. Goldman Sachs International [2015] EWHC 759 (Comm), a very late amendment being one which would cause the trial date to be lost. In the case of a very late amendment, there is a heavy onus to justify it.
In the current case the trial was still in “the dim and distant future” and disclosure had not taken place. The amendments were also as a result of the finding at the preliminary hearing, and it was still technically open to CNM to issue fresh proceedings against the receivers if it were denied permission to amend. All of which put the amendment in the category of late rather than very late.
Therefore, in considering what test to apply in the case of a late amendment the Court of Appeal concluded that “unless it can be seen that a claim has no real prospect of succeeding, its merits should be determined at a full trial”. The court has to perform a balancing act between “the injustice to the party seeking to amend if it is refused permission, against the need for finality in litigation and the injustice to the other parties and other litigants” but apart from in the case of very late amendments, the court found that the perceived strength of the case should not normally a factor to be taken into account.
The court reiterated that the warnings against mini trials apply with just as much force to applications to amend as they do to summary judgment or jurisdiction disputes.
Reconsideration of the proposed amendments
In reconsidering the two proposed amendments, the Court of Appeal held that it would be unjust to refuse permission to amend not least because this was not a case where “the amendments will cause substantial duplication of cost and effort: disclosure has not taken place and…[and] the basic factual disputes are the same as they ever were”.
However, in the event, the parties reached a full settlement in respect of all claims just before the judgement was handed down.
Comment
This is a useful case for those dealing with either the interpretation of an Unless order and whether relief from sanction sis required and also for cases where there is a late application to amend the pleadings.