Single-Sex Workplace Facilities, Trans Rights and the Law
What Employers Need to Know
The Supreme Court’s decision in For Women Scotland in 2024 was one of the most significant equality law judgments of recent years. But for employers, it did not produce a simple, universal rule for every workplace situation involving sex, gender reassignment and access to facilities. Instead, the legal position has become clearer in some respects and more complicated in others.
The central point is that employers must now understand both the effect of For Women Scotland and the way subsequent Employment Tribunal decisions are applying the law in practice. The safest approach is not to rely on slogans or assumptions, but to take a careful, evidence-based approach to policies, facilities and individual complaints.
What did For Women Scotland decide?
The Supreme Court held that, for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010, references to “man”, “woman” and “sex” mean biological sex.
However, the Court was careful to limit its judgment to the interpretation of the Equality Act. It expressly said that it was not deciding wider social or political arguments about the meaning of sex or gender. The decision also does not remove legal protection from trans people.
Gender reassignment remains a protected characteristic under section 7 of the Equality Act 2010. Protection applies to a person who is proposing to undergo, is undergoing or has undergone a process for the purpose of reassigning their sex.
The Gender Recognition Act 2004 also continues to have important legal effects, including protections relating to privacy and the disclosure of a person’s gender history.
For employers, therefore, the position is not simply that one set of rights has replaced another. Sex remains protected, gender reassignment remains protected, and difficult workplace situations can involve a genuine conflict between the rights and interests of different employees.
Toilets, washing facilities and changing rooms
Much of the practical difficulty arises around workplace facilities. The Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 require employers to provide suitable and sufficient toilets, washing facilities and changing facilities.
In broad terms, the Regulations provide for separate facilities for men and women, except in some circumstances where individual facilities are contained in separate lockable rooms. Changing facilities must also be separate where necessary for reasons of propriety. Failure to comply with the relevant Regulations can amount to a strict liability criminal offence.
The difficulty is that For Women Scotland interpreted the Equality Act 2010, not the 1992 Regulations. The Supreme Court did not decide how “men” and “women” should be interpreted for the purposes of those Regulations.
That has led to differing approaches in subsequent Employment Tribunal cases.
In Kelly v Leonardo UK Ltd, the Tribunal rejected claims arising from a trans-inclusive toilet policy and took the view that Regulation 20 was concerned primarily with the physical characteristics of the facilities rather than simply who was permitted to use them.
By contrast, in LS v NHS England, the Tribunal concluded that allowing trans women to use women’s toilets meant the employer was not providing single-sex facilities for women within the meaning of the Regulations.
In Peggie v Fife Health Board, however, the Tribunal said that For Women Scotland did not determine the meaning of “men” and “women” under the 1992 Regulations, because the Supreme Court had specifically confined its analysis to the Equality Act.
And in the Darlington nurses case, the Tribunal again interpreted the Regulations in line with biological sex and found that requiring women to share communal changing facilities in the circumstances could amount to harassment and indirect sex discrimination.
For employers, the important point is that this area is not yet entirely settled.
Competing protected rights
The cases also demonstrate that disputes cannot simply be resolved by identifying which employee has a protected characteristic.
In Peggie, the Tribunal described the dispute as a conflict between protected rights and applied a proportionality analysis. The question was not simply who was “right”, but whether the employer’s approach was justified and whether a less intrusive alternative could have been adopted.
Gender-critical beliefs may themselves qualify for protection under the Equality Act, as may beliefs supportive of trans rights. However, there is an important distinction between holding a protected belief and the way in which that belief is expressed.
The courts have made clear that dismissal simply because somebody holds or expresses a protected belief may amount to discrimination. But where the issue is the particular way that belief has been manifested, proportionality becomes relevant.
That means employers must be cautious about disciplinary action on either side of a dispute. An employee cannot necessarily be sanctioned simply for holding a gender-critical belief, but nor does that give an unrestricted right to express that belief in any manner towards colleagues.
What should employers do?
The most useful lessons from the recent cases are practical:
- Review existing policies. A policy written several years ago may no longer reflect the current legal landscape. Employers should review policies relating to toilets, changing rooms, gender reassignment, dignity at work and harassment.
- Carry out an equality impact assessment before introducing or changing policies on facilities. Employers should consider the effect of any policy on all affected groups, rather than focusing on only one protected characteristic. Tribunals have criticised employers for failing to carry out this exercise.
- Carry out a risk assessment. Employers should consider the actual physical environment, privacy, the nature of communal facilities, the needs of individual employees and whether alternative arrangements are available.
- Consult. Where appropriate, employers should speak to affected employees, staff groups and unions before implementing policies. A lack of meaningful consultation was identified as a problem in the cases considered.
- Consider practical alternatives. In some workplaces, individual lockable facilities may reduce conflict significantly. In others, additional or alternative provision may be possible. Employers should avoid assuming that one employee must simply accept an arrangement without considering whether there is a less discriminatory solution.
- Communicate clearly. Employees should understand what the policy is and what facilities are available. A solution is of limited value if staff do not know that it exists.
- Deal with complaints quickly and carefully. Where an employee raises concerns, employers should take appropriate action within a reasonable timeframe, which may include a written complaint, grievance process or HR involvement. Delays themselves can create legal risk. In Peggie, the unreasonable length of an investigation became part of a successful harassment claim.
- Keep policies under review. Employers should be prepared to reassess arrangements if they are not working in practice or if the legal position develops further.
The practical message for employers
The law requires employers to recognise competing protected rights, provide lawful facilities, avoid discrimination and harassment, and make proportionate decisions.
There may not always be a solution that satisfies every employee completely. But an employer that can demonstrate that it has assessed the legal position, considered the impact on all affected groups, consulted, explored alternatives and responded reasonably to complaints will be in a far stronger position than one that simply adopts a blanket policy and assumes the issue is settled.
If you’d like to discuss any of the issues raised by this article, please get in touch.
The legal content provided by RSW Law Limited is for information purposes only and should not be relied on in any specific case without legal or other professional advice.
Copyright is owned by RSW Law Limited and all rights in such copyright are reserved.